Zionsville’s girls golf team makes history winning state title


From left, front row, Maggie Nobbe and Claire Edwards. Back row, ZCHS principal Tim East, coach Jeff Anderson, Ellie Hine, Abby Theilbar, Avery VonDielingen, Annabelle Pancake, assistant coach Susan Theilbar and athletic director Greg Schellhase. (Photo by Mark Ambrogi)

For Zionsville Community High School coach Jeff Anderson, one of the best parts of his team winning the school’s first  girls state golf championship  was sharing the moment with past members.

“It was cool. I saw a lot of familiar faces from the past (Saturday),” said Anderson, who has been the coach for 10 seasons. “It was neat to see parents and former players come back and support the program. It’s a family that we have and we grow every year. These kids have done an outstanding job.”

The Eagles won the title Sept. 30 at Carmel’s Prairie View Golf Club with a score of 620, 18 strokes fewer than second-place Westfield.

“It’s special to get that first one,” sophomore Annabelle Pancake said.

Previously, Zionsville’s best finish was third in 2013. The Eagles were fourth last year.

Zionsville set a state finals 18-hole record with a 299 Sept. 29, one stroke fewer than the previous mark of 300 by Carmel in 2013 at The Legends Golf Club in Franklin.

“They knew they couldn’t be complacent with the quality of opponent of a Westfield and Evansville North,” Anderson said. “They were fully capable of doing what we did (Friday). We had to play our game and stay within ourselves.”

Despite the sizable lead, Anderson said there were concerns.

“We were blowing up the back nine,” he said. “We had double bogeys and triple bogeys. I didn’t know where things were going to fall with the other teams.  We were nervous until the 18th hole. But we were focused and did what we needed to do.”

Pancake led the Eagles with a 149 (74-75) two-round total to finish fourth in the state.

“Going into (the final round), everybody was saying stay calm, don’t get too comfortable,” Pancake said. “Also, don’t get too nervous. You have to play the game you know. I started off pretty slow. I had a lot of lip-outs. It ended up coming together at the end. It wasn’t my best day, but I had a lot of fun with everyone.”

Eagles sophomore Abby Theilbar was tied for seventh with a 154 (70-84).  Junior Avery VonDielingen shot 156 (77-81). Senior Claire Edwards had a pair of 81s for a 162 and senior Maggie Nobbe was right behind with a 163 (78-85).

Although the Eagles will miss those senior starters, Anderson said, “we have a solid core to build around, that’s for sure.”

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, https://www.youarecurrent.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact