Fifth-generation Hamilton County resident pens ‘Legendary Locals of Carmel’

“Legendary Locals of Carmel” released on June 6. (Submitted photo)

“Legendary Locals of Carmel” released on June 6. (Submitted photo)

By Ann Marie Shambaugh

A fifth-generation Hamilton County resident and historian, Debra Haskett May agrees that she was a perfect fit to write about some of the most impactful figures in Carmel history.

“Legendary Locals of Carmel” highlights 100 people who have left their mark on the city, from French trapper and fur trader Jean Brouillette to current Mayor Jim Brainard, who is serving his sixth term in office.



“I love people, I love history, and I love making connections, so it was kind of a fun project,” said May, a Carmel resident and operations manager for the Westfield Chamber of Commerce.

Arcadia Publishing asked May to write the book after coming across the weekly newsletter she penned for the Carmel Clay Historical Society, where she previously served as vice president and program director. The Carmel edition released June 6 and is the fifth in the “Legendary Locals” series in Indiana, following books featuring Aurora, Auburn, Columbus and Fort Wayne.

Before agreeing to write the book, May – a first-time author – made a list of people she could include to make sure she could come up with enough content. That ended up being the easy part, she said, as she sometimes ran into roadblocks during her research and had to scratch some names off the list. But other names kept popping up.

“I could probably throw out a list for a volume two, but I’m not writing it,” she said.

May, a 1978 Carmel High School graduate, said she learned a lot during two years of research and writing. She found Worthington E. Hagerman, an artist and international traveler, to be the most interesting.

“His story is just so intriguing and secretive that you want to learn more,” she said.

Although she’s thankful that the book is done, her research inspired her to launch another project with historical ties. She is working with Clay Township Trustee Doug Callahan – former chief of the Carmel Fire Dept. – and others to raise money to place bronze plaques at two gravesites.

“Carmel has only had one police officer in its history killed in the line of duty, and it’s only had one firefighter in its history killed in the line of duty, and neither of their graves are marked as such,” May said. “It should be recorded for history.”

Find the book

“Legendary Locals of Carmel” is available at, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Walgreens and several shops in Carmel. Learn more at

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact