Update: Westfield double homicide suspect arrested

Christian Haley

Christian Haley

An Indianapolis man was arrested tonight in connection with the Westfield double homicide on Dec. 20.

Christian Rene Haley, 20, has been charged with two counts of murder, two counts of felony murder, one count of robbery (a felony), one count of burglary (a felony) and theft. He has been transported to the Hamilton County Jail.

Police began investigating the killing of a mother and daughter found dead in their Westfield home on Dec. 20 after being called to the home in the 15000 block of Oak Park Court at 4:42 p.m. by a relative. Once there, officers found the Marylyn Erb, 52, and Kelley Erb, 23, unresponsive and with visible injuries to their bodies. Each was pronounced dead at the scene.

WPD Cpt. Charles E. Hollowell said the case was treated as a homicide due to evidence at the scene.

Kelley Erb

Kelley Erb

“It has been determined that this home invasion robbery occurred during the midday hours of Friday, Dec. 20, and the initial investigation did not reveal the evidence of forced entry. Additionally, both victims died as a result of blunt force trauma,” Hollowell stated. “Additionally, it was determined that the victim’s home was not randomly selected by this individual.”

Hollowell said a 2011 Maroon Buick Enclave was taken from the home and was found a short distance away on East 161st Street. Anyone with information related to this incident, if anyone saw the driver of the Buick Enclave or anyone wanting to report any suspicious persons and/or activities seen in the area, are asked to contact the Westfield Criminal Investigations Division at 773-1300 or Crime Stoppers at 262-8477.

“Citizens have been great with giving us different tips they think may be useful,” Hollowell said.

This investigation has been a multiagency effort that consisted of officers from the Westfield, Noblesville, Carmel, Lawrence and Indianapolis Metropolitan police departments; Hamilton County’s sheriffs, prosecutors and coroners offices; Indiana State Police and the U.S. Marshalls.

Marylyn Erb

Marylyn Erb

“The City of Westfield would like to thank them for their ongoing assistance and resources dedicated to this investigation,” Hollowell said. “With state and Hamilton County agencies, mutual aid is superb. The additional resources are a benefit.”

Attempts to contact the Erb family were not returned.

Kelley was a student at Ivy Tech, where she was pursuing her degree in early childhood education. A graduate of Heritage Christian High School, she previously studied at Indiana Wesleyan University. Kelley loved animals, especially dogs and horses, and singing in her high school choir.

Kelley Erb’s obituary notice

Marylyn was a homemaker. She grew up in Lowell and earned her nursing degree from Indiana University. Marylyn was said to have a passion for serving her family and loved spending time with her grandchildren. She and husband, Todd, celebrated their 30th anniversary in February.

Marylyn Erb’s obituary notice

Senior Pastor Dave Rodriguez said the Erb family has belonged to the Grace Community Church in Noblesville congregation for many years and were active members. Marylyn was a member of a small group and involved in the church’s women’s group and Kelley was part of a young adults organization and also served in Grace Kids.

“Our hearts break for the Erb family and everyone who has been impacted by this horrific act. We do not know why tragedies like this happen,” Rodriguez said.

Hollowell said this is the first homicide in Westfield since Nicholas Reners’ death in July 2008.

This is an ongoing and active investigation, for ongoing coverage of the investigation, visit youarecurrent.com.

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, https://www.youarecurrent.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact