Where’s Amy attends ‘Come From Away’ Amy Pauszek 4 years ago Julie Whitehead (Indianapolis), Kelly Alexiou (Fishers), Mike Kueper (Fishers) and Krissy Oeff (Geist). Julie Whitehead (Indianapolis), Kelly Alexiou (Fishers), Mike Kueper (Fishers) and Krissy Oeff (Geist). Evan Cohen (Carmel) and Sadie Cohen (Carmel) with parents Melissa and Marc Cohen (Carmel). Where’s Amy attended Broadway Indy’s Jan. 21 opening night of the Tony Award-winning musical “Come from Away.” More Headlines