Meet the maker: Kauffman Fine Furniture founder Justin Kauffman celebrates 10 years in Noblesville 


Noblesville resident Justin Kauffman developed an interest in making handmade furniture after his wife’s grandfather, Ted Lacey, helped him build a simple hope chest.

Kauffman built the chest, his first piece of furniture, in 2000. More than two decades later, he’s celebrating the 10th anniversary of Kauffman Fine Furniture in Noblesville.

Kauffman married his wife Audra in 2002, and then the couple moved to Boston to attend graduate school. Kauffman obtained master’s degrees in Old Testament and Biblical Languages but never lost his interest in furniture making.

“When we lived in Boston, the landlady let me use the cellar of the house and I continued to work with my hands,” said Kauffman, 44. “When I graduated, I decided I would prefer to work with my hands than with my mind.”

So, Kauffman enrolled in the North Bennet Street School, the oldest trade school in the U.S. Shortly thereafter, he developed an appreciation for making 18th century-style furniture.

“The training at North Bennet Street focused on that period and those styles, but I would still prefer it, anyway, even if the school hadn’t focused on that,” he said. “To me, it represents the pinnacle of furniture. The designs, the embellishments were phenomenal and are unsurpassed in furniture making. The carving, the inlay, the proportions – they’re still appealing today to many people.

“They fit in historic homes and even in modern homes.”

Kauffman graduated from trade school in 2007, and he and his wife moved to Pendleton, where Kauffman started his fine furniture company. The couple moved to Noblesville in 2012.

CIN COVER 0111 justin kauffman9
A Chapin highboy with Cartouche made by Justin Kauffman. (Photo courtesy of Justin Kauffman)

Most of Kauffman’s work is commissioned.

“I do several shows a year,” Kauffman said. “I exhibit in furniture shows and period artisan and craftsman shows. I set up some spec pieces I’ve built and take commissions, so 90 percent of my business is commission work. Occasionally, somebody will happen upon my website.”

When a client commissions a piece of work, they may want something original, something replicated from a book or something replicated from a museum. If the client wants a museum replica, Kauffman will sometimes visit the museum to study the piece and take photos to ensure his piece is truly a replica.

One such piece was commissioned by Wendy Williams, a resident of Haddonfield, N.J.

Williams met Kauffman at a show in Pennsylvania, where she purchased a Queen Anne dresser. She later commissioned several pieces, including two side chairs. One of the original chairs was held at Winterthur Museum, Garden and Library in Delaware.

“He and I visited Winterthur with one of the gracious people there so he could study it, and he made two chairs for me,” Williams said. “I’ve commissioned quite a few pieces from him. He is an absolute master at choosing wood and using that in the design of the piece. There’s a beautiful flow and fluidity to his pieces. I think he’s a treasure.

“I think he truly is a treasure, because he’s continuing an amazing craft that few people have the skill or willingness to do anymore. He’s making beautiful art pieces for everyone’s home.”

Besides indoor shows, Kauffman also participates in period reenactments and outdoor shows.

“I have a period tent and a period outfit, and I do the same thing at outdoor shows as I do indoor,” Kauffman said. “It’s just I dress in period attire.”

Shows are usually on the East Coast.

“That’s due primarily to the fact that people who live out there are familiar with this kind of furniture, and they appreciate it and want it for their 18th-century house,” Kauffman said.

Kauffman’s pieces can take up to 500 hours to finish. Prices range from a few hundred dollars to tens of thousands of dollars, depending on the piece.

“Some people want something simple like a nightstand or a little accent table,” Kauffman said. “Other people want something highly ornate. They want carvings or special veneers or inlay that elevates a simple dining table to more of a piece of art.”

Some of Kauffman’s clients are repeat customers, such as Jim Connolly, a resident of Fredericksburg, Va.

Connolly, a U.S. Marine Corps veteran, discovered Kauffman at a French Indian War Market Fair in spring 2020. Connolly purchased a mirror.

“He had some wares for sale, and he had a small Chippendale mirror I’ve been looking for but couldn’t find in any quality,” Connolly said. “He had one with tiger-striped maple. I was really taken with it and how pretty it was.”

Connolly was carrying only a credit card, and Kauffman didn’t accept credit cards.

“My checkbook was at home,” Connolly said. “So, (Kauffman) said, ‘Take it home and send me a check if you like it, and if not, send it back to me,’ which I found incredible in this day and age. So, I took it home and immediately wrote a check and asked him to make a shelf. It hangs in the doorway of my home. It’s an iconic piece of Americana that hangs in my house.”

Connolly later commissioned another mirror, which Kauffman is building. It pays tribute to the Marine Corps.

“I don’t have the words to describe how good it is,” Connolly said of Kauffman’s work. “He has a lot of attention to detail, and he’s a perfectionist in his craft. I don’t mind paying good money for good workmanship and good materials. Anybody interested in period furniture from the 18th century, Justin is the guy to see. I don’t think there’s anything he can’t make out of wood.”

Not surprisingly, Kauffman pays fine attention to detail.

“Everything I make is built like it would’ve been built back then,” Kauffman said. “The joinery is hand-cut and hand fit. There are dovetail drawers. That ensures their piece will last for as long as these beautiful pieces we admire today have lasted.”

Besides making furniture, Kauffman teaches Latin and Greek at Highland Latin School in Carmel.

For more, visit

CIN COVER 0111 justin kauffman6
Justin Kauffman sometimes cuts down trees himself to use in his furniture making. (Photo courtesy of Justin Kauffman)

From start to finish

Justin Kauffman many times has a hand in his work from start to finish – such as he even cuts down the trees he uses.

“One reason I harvest my own logs is because I can get the whole log, and that means if I build a large piece of furniture, every piece in that piece of furniture is made out of a board from the same log,” Kauffman said. “So, the color matches, the figure matches. I can get especially wide boards, which are important for me because many pieces I’m building require wide boards. That would be difficult to find in a normal lumber yard.”

Kauffman mostly uses walnut, mahogany, cherry and figured maple. He loads the felled tree on trailer and takes it to a sawmill.
“I’m there when the sawyer is cutting,” he said. “I’m examining the log as the blade passes through it and say, ‘Oh, we need to turn it,’ or, ‘I want it this thickness.’ It’s very customized because I know what the end product will be.”

Sometimes, Kauffman air dries the lumber, which takes a year per inch of thickness. Specifically, he gets better results with walnut and cherry — per color and easier workability — when air dried.

If Kauffman wants to use mahogany or tiger maple, he must travel to a lumber yard in north central Pennsylvania because those species don’t grow in the Midwest.

Kauffman draws inspiration from several 18th-century craftsmen, especially from the work of Thomas Tufft, a furniture maker in Philadelphia in the late 1700s, and Eliphalet Chapin, a furniture maker who was trained in Philadelphia and then moved to the Connecticut River Valley.

All of Kauffman’s furniture is finished with a hand-rubbed finish.