Noblesville group opposes Beaver Materials proposal


Beaver Materials is proposing a gravel extraction site on 50 acres northwest of Allisonville Road and 191st Street. (Submitted image)

A group of Noblesville neighbors weren’t thrilled when Beaver Materials presented plans to establish a gravel extraction site near Potter’s Bridge Park. So, they decided to take action.

The group, comprised of neighbors from Potter’s Woods, Fairfield Farms and Allison Trails, formed Sept. 24 after Beaver Materials conducted a community neighborhood meeting earlier in September. Group members began calling the group “Don’t Leave it to Beaver.”

“At that point, everyone broke up into different groups based on potential issues they felt the most passionate about, whether that was air pollution, water quality, traffic safety, noise levels, so forth and so on,” said Rachael Raymer, a neighbor who is handling media relations for the group. “Everybody broke up into groups and elected different leaders to coordinate people on their research.”

Beaver Materials proposes is to establish a gravel and sand extraction site on 50 acres northwest of 191st Street and Allisonville Road. If approved, Beaver Materials will purchase the property and immediately donate a portion of it to Hamilton County Parks and Recreation to expand Potter’s Bridge Park. After 10 years of extraction, the company pledged to allow Hamilton County Parks and Recreation to use the remaining land for additional expansions to Potter’s Bridge Park.

The Don’t Leave it to Beaver group is trying to stop the proposal.

“We have yet to hear of any compromises that would take care of all of our concerns, and most of our concerns are around the health and safety of our community, whether it’s truck traffic or pollution in the air or pollution in the water damaging our ecosystem, so it’s hard to think around what would be a compromise to take care of those things,” Raymer said. “But, if a compromise exists, we would love to hear it. We haven’t heard of it yet, so we are campaigning to stop it.”

The proposal will appear before the Noblesville Plan Commission during its Nov. 16 meeting. A public hearing is scheduled, and after that, the plan commission will make a favorable or unfavorable recommendation. The proposal will then advance to the Noblesville Common Council, which will vote to approve or deny.

Although Raymer said the group wants to see the park system expanded, she said the Beaver Materials proposal doesn’t seem the best way to do it.

“We love our parks, and particularly we love that park because it’s so close to where we all live,” she said. “However, a park expansion that could bring increased heavy truck traffic, potential air pollution, potential ecosystem impacts and downstream infrastructure impacts is not a good compromise for the end results.”

Some of the research the group has been conducting shows that gravel pit lakes are more dangerous than natural lakes because they can cause steep drop-offs.

“Beaver Materials told us they would slope the gravel pit lake per regulations,” Raymer said. “However, if that’s what they did at Koteewi (Lake), those slopes are still really steep. So much so that danger signs are posted around the fence line and they won’t allow swimming for that reason.”

As of press time, a petition on to stop the proposal has received more than 3,700 signatures. For more, visit For more on the Beaver Materials proposal, visit


Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact