Late Carmel attorney remembered as ‘champion of history’ 


A longtime Carmel attorney is being remembered for his role in redevelopment of the Arts & Design District. 

Carmel resident Curtis Butcher, 81, died Oct. 19. He began practicing law in Carmel in 1975, and 10 years later bought the building on the northwest corner of Main Street and Range Line Road, where he moved his office to the second floor.


The building — on the site of a former trading post used by a French fur trader — was completed in 1923 to house Citizens State Bank. In 1938, it became Brown’s Drug Store, then became home to Union State Bank from 1954 to 1972. Several insurance agencies officed there until 1985, when Butcher bought the building.

Butcher remodeled the first floor using marble and mosaic floors, installed chandeliers from the L.S. Ayers Tea Room and added 100-year-old double doors from the former Morrison Opera House in downtown Indianapolis.

Dan Moriarity, founder of Studio M Architecture & Planning, has rented space in the building for seven years.

“Mr. Butcher was a ‘gentleman’s gentleman,’” Moriarity said. “He was always smiling, patient, helpful and ready to do anything he could to improve the Arts & Design District. We will certainly miss him.”

Mark Dollase, vice president of Indiana Landmarks and on staff for the Carmel Historic Preservation Commission, said he got to know Butcher after Mayor Jim Brainard appointed him to the commission in 2012.

“I didn’t know Curtis before his appointment, but quickly grew fond of him due to his great wisdom, sharp legal mind and sense of humor,” Dollase said. “Curtis was always enthusiastic about the mission of the preservation commission, as he valued the city’s heritage and was the steward of a historic building himself. He will certainly be missed by myself and his fellow commissioners.”

Brainard described Butcher as a “champion of history in Carmel.”

“With his purchase of the building at the corner of Range Line Road and Main Street, he was among the first to show faith in what was then our old town district,” Brainard said. “He served on our city Historic Preservation Commission and played an important role in shaping what has become the Arts & Design District. His contributions to Carmel will continue long beyond his lifetime.”

Butcher was born Aug. 11, 1939, in Monroe County. He earned degrees in law accounting from Indiana University. He served as Indiana’s deputy attorney general for two years.

Survivors include his wife, Mary Ann (Hiatt) Butcher; children, Lora Butcher and Jason Butcher; and sister, Brenda Earnshaw.

Family and friends gathered for a funeral service Oct. 24 at Northview Church.

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact