Full hands, full hearts: Family leaves city living to become first-generation farmers in north Noblesville


In unincorporated Noblesville, in its far northeast reaches, sits Full Hand Farm.

The average person driving by wouldn’t have a clue of its existence because the farm is  far back off the road. But once you’ve driven down the curving driveway up to a small home, the farm’s main green house can be seen adjacent, with rows of hoop houses even further back.

Stepping into the hoop houses is like entering a different season, with floors covered in green, from an assortment of leafy greens to a variety of root vegetables.

Husband and wife Eli Robb and Genesis McKiernan-Allen are the owners, having taken root on the 25-acre property – a former horse farm they bought on Craigslist – five years ago to start their own local, organic farm.

“Neither of us come from a farming background or land, but we felt that we wanted to work outside, and we wanted to work together,” McKiernan-Allen said. “We spent a number of years where I was working in high-end restaurants as a server, and he was working construction. We were basically ships passing in the night. We wanted a family, and we knew what we were doing wasn’t working for a family life.”

Now, they have a son, Ezra, 4, and a daughter, Flora, who will be 2 in May.

“(Ezra) was actually the catalyst for beginning to do this full time,” McKiernan-Allen said. “I still had a restaurant job (when I got pregnant) to help capitalize the farm.”

Considered a four-season farm, the family produces food year-round, farming approximately 5 acres outdoors. This year, they’ll farm an additional 3 acres at a nearby farm. During winter months, they move production to their greenhouse and 10 hoop houses, a round-topped structure that protects rows of plantings from harsh weather using large hoop-like supports that are covered in heavy plastic sheeting.

“A lot of our success is doing year-round production,” McKiernan-Allen said. “It’s not like we could be growing tomatoes all year. This time of year, it’s all about planting the right crops – spinach, kale, chard – cold, hardy plants that are bred to actually grow better in the cold. It’s year-round income. If we don’t sell things in the winter, we don’t make money in the winter. A lot of farmers who don’t do four-season production are under a higher pressure to get a part-time seasonal job or having to budget for the entire year from what you’re making in the summer. We also enjoy the challenge that goes into four-season farming, and we can keep employees year-round as well.”

In the dead of winter, the couple is already working on production for its busy season, preparing the start of peas, beets, kale and vegetables. Planning begins about two years out for each season.

“A basic tenant of organic farming is crop rotation, so we’re not fertilizing with anything besides using cover crop, and we rotate, so we’re not pulling the same nutrients from the same piece of ground,” McKiernan-Allen said.

Because they had no background in farming, Robb and McKiernan-Allen completed a two-year apprenticeship at a community-supported farm in Iowa.

“That was where we cut our teeth. We learned a lot there,” McKiernan-Allen said. “We are not a CSA, and they were not a four-season farm, so there definitely were some things that didn’t quite translate. We built our base there, and then from there we attended conferences, we read a lot, we talk to other farmers, and actually social media is amazing as well. There’s a big online sharing community. The national community of organic, local farmers at our scale is not that big.”

McKiernan-Allen said food from the farm is sold to local farmers markets and local restaurants.

In the summer, Full Hand Farm is the exclusive vendor to the Broad Ripple Farmers Market, which operates year-round. In the winter, it is a vendor at the Indy Winter Farmers Market.

Because the couple doesn’t sell products at grocery stores, and because the farm isn’t set up for people to stop by and shop, those looking to buy have to do so at farmers markets. Or, customers can purchase items from a fresh-produce case at Wheeler’s Cafe, just across from the farm. The café is attached to Mercantile 37, 25625 Ind. 37, a store of local and vintage home décor that opened in September 2018. Wheeler’s Café is a small restaurant and coffee shop.

“We stock items over there a couple of times a week, and it’s been really fun to have that as an outlet,” McKiernan-Allen said.

In addition to Wheeler’s Café, Full Hand Farm sells to approximately 25 other restaurants in the Indianapolis area, including nearly every Café Patachou, Petite Chou, Public Greens, Napolese, Bluebeard, Milktooth, Wildwood, The Meridian Restaurant, Late Harvest Kitchen and North End Barbecue, among others.

“We joke that our whole life is about food – growing it, cooking it, eating it, trying to get our kids to eat it,” McKiernan-Allen said. “It’s meaningful to us to share that.”

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, https://www.youarecurrent.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact